Why read this: This article asks an uncomfortable but important question: how should governments decide how much to spend on cleaner air, when the benefit is fewer people getting sick or dying? It introduces students to cost-benefit analysis, a key idea in economics and public policy, and shows how economists have tried — and sometimes failed — to put a number on a human life. The piece will help your students see that policy choices about pollution, healthcare, and safety are not just moral debates but also problems of measurement, and that a difficult number is often more useful than no number at all.
What to notice: Encourage students to track the writer's argument across the article rather than judging single sentences. Notice how the opening question ("How much is fresh air really worth?") returns at the end, but with a much firmer answer. Watch for hedging language such as "may," "might," "could," and "perhaps," which signals that the writer is being careful and tentative. Pay attention to two named methods — the human-capital method and the value of a statistical life — and what each one fails to do. Students should also notice the writer's use of contrast: officials versus critics, then versus now, perfect answers versus useful ones.
Skills practised: Reading at this level practises following a multi-step argument across several paragraphs without losing the thread. Students will work with subordinate clauses ("...because it gave a value of zero to anyone without a paid job"), passive forms ("a figure called the value of a statistical life"), and modal hedging. The text introduces five key economic terms — cost-benefit analysis, regulation, red tape, human-capital method, and value of a statistical life — that students will meet again in social studies, economics, and current-affairs reading. Comprehension tasks ask students to identify reasons in the text, evaluate an idea using evidence, and recognise the writer's overall stance.
How do you put a price on a human life?
It sounds uncomfortable, but the alternative may be worse
Tap any green word in the article to see its meaning.
How much is fresh air really worth? Standing on a mountain top, breathing deeplydeeply: In large volume. — 深深地;大口地, you might say the answer is “everything”. Yet cleaning up dirty air costs real money. Factories must buy new equipment, some industries may need to shrinkshrink: To become smaller; to contract. — 缩小;萎缩, and householdshousehold: All the persons who live in a given house or other home; a family including attendants, servants etc.; a domestic or family establishment. — 家庭;户 need cleaner ways of cooking and heating. The benefit, on the other side, is that fewer people get sick from breathing polluted air, especially children, the old, and those already ill. Deciding how much to spend on clean air is therefore a classicclassic: Exemplary of a particular style; defining a class or category; typical; archetypical; epitomic. — 典型的 problem of cost-benefit analysis: an economic method that compares the money spent on something with the benefits gained, to decide if it is worth doing — 成本效益分析, in which one side of the argument must be weighed against the other. But how do you measure a benefit that means avoiding sickness or early death? Pricing fresh air becomes an even harder question: how do you put a value on a human life?
This is a question that America’s Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has now decided to stop asking. Last month it announced that, when judging new pollution rules, it would no longer try to put a price on the health benefits of cleaner air. Officialsofficial: An office holder, a person holding an official position in government, sports, or other organization. — 官员 argued there was simply too much uncertaintyuncertainty: Doubt; the condition of being uncertain or without conviction. — 不确定性 about what those benefits are worth. Criticscritic: One who criticizes; a person who finds fault. — 批评者;挑剔的人, however, see this as a quiet way to water down: to weaken something (usually a rule or statement) by making it less strict — 削弱 / 打折扣 regulationregulation: The act of regulating or the condition of being regulated. — 监管. As the old saying goes, what is not counted does not count.
The American government has required this kind of analysis since 1981, when President Ronald Reagan ordered federalfederal: Pertaining to the national government level in a federal nation, as opposed to state, provincial, county, city, or town. — 联邦的 agenciesagency: A department or other administrative unit of a government; also, the office or headquarters of, or the district administered by, such unit of government. — (政府)机构;局 to weigh the costs of new rules against their benefits. His aim was to cut red tape: excessive bureaucratic rules and procedures that slow things down — 繁文缛节 / 官僚程序 that, in his view, cost businesses more than it was worth. If a pollution rule saved only a few lives but spent a great deal of money, the argument went, the same money might save more lives elsewhereelsewhere: Synonym of somewhere else: in, at, or to some other place. — 在别处;到别处 — fundingfunding: The action of the verb fund. — 资助;提供资金 hospitals, for example. Critics replied that no honest number could be placed on a human life. Oddly, today’s EPA sounds rather like those critics from forty years ago.
Earlier economistseconomist: An expert in economics, especially one who studies economic data and extracts higher-level information or proposes theories. — 经济学家 had tried to solve the problem with what became known as the human-capital method: an older approach that priced a person's life as their remaining lifetime earnings, later rejected because it assigned zero value to non-earners — 人力资本法. A person’s life, they suggested, could be valued at the wageswage: An amount of money paid to a worker for a specified quantity of work, usually calculated on an hourly basis and expressed in an amount of money per hour. — 工资 they would have earned if they had lived. Wages, after all, roughlyroughly: Without precision or exactness; imprecisely but close to in quantity or amount; approximately. — 大约;大致 show what people are willingwilling: Ready to do something, particularly something that requires change or effort; not objecting. — 愿意的;乐意的 to accept for the hours of their working lives. The approachapproach: A manner of making (a policy) or solving (a problem, etc.). — 方法;途径 was eventually rejected, because it gave a value of zero to anyone without a paid job — retired people, the sick, and parents caring for children at home. Lifetimelifetime: The duration of the life of someone or something. — 一生;终生 earningsearnings: Business profits. — 收益;利润, it turned out, are not the same as a lifetime’s value.
A better idea came from Thomas Schelling, who later won a Nobel prize in economicseconomics: Chiefly with a descriptive word: the application of this study to a particular domain. — (某领域的)经济学. Schelling pointed out that we all take small risks of dying every day. Driving a car, for example, carries some chance of a fatalfatal: Causing death or destruction. — 致命的;毁灭性的 crash, and spending a little more on safety features lowerslower: To reduce the degree, intensity, strength, etc., of. — 降低(程度);减弱 that chance. By measuring how much people are willing to pay to reduce their risk of death by a tiny amount, economists can work out a figure called the value of a statisticalstatistical: Of or pertaining to statistics. — 统计的 life. If 100,000 people each pay $100 to avoid a one-in-100,000 chance of dying, then $10 million has effectively been spent to prevent one expected death. The figure does not say what a life is worth; it shows what people will pay to protect it. The EPA itself has long used a figure of around twelve million dollars per statistical life.
None of these methods give a perfect answer, and perhaps no method ever will. Yet the value of a life is clearly not zero. People generally want to stay alive, and they are willing to pay something to do so. Regulatorsregulator: A person or group that sets standards of practice, especially regulatory law as sanctioned by statutory law. — 监管机构 need a benchmarkbenchmark: A standard by which something is evaluated or measured. — 基准;标准, even an imperfectimperfect: Not perfect. — 不完美的 one, against which the costs of their decisions can be measured. Economists are sometimes accusedaccuse: To find fault with, blame, censure. — 指责;责备 of cold-heartedness for asking how much a life is worth. Refusing to ask the question, however, would be far worse.
How much is fresh air really worth? Standing on a mountain top, breathing deeplydeeply: In large volume. — 深深地;大口地, you might say the answer is “everything”. Yet cleaning up dirty air costs real money. Factories must buy new equipment, some industries may need to shrinkshrink: To become smaller; to contract. — 缩小;萎缩, and householdshousehold: All the persons who live in a given house or other home; a family including attendants, servants etc.; a domestic or family establishment. — 家庭;户 need cleaner ways of cooking and heating. The benefit, on the other side, is that fewer people get sick from breathing polluted air, especially children, the old, and those already ill. Deciding how much to spend on clean air is therefore a classicclassic: Exemplary of a particular style; defining a class or category; typical; archetypical; epitomic. — 典型的 problem of cost-benefit analysis: an economic method that compares the money spent on something with the benefits gained, to decide if it is worth doing — 成本效益分析, in which one side of the argument must be weighed against the other. But how do you measure a benefit that means avoiding sickness or early death? Pricing fresh air becomes an even harder question: how do you put a value on a human life?
This is a question that America’s Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has now decided to stop asking. Last month it announced that, when judging new pollution rules, it would no longer try to put a price on the health benefits of cleaner air. Officialsofficial: An office holder, a person holding an official position in government, sports, or other organization. — 官员 argued there was simply too much uncertaintyuncertainty: Doubt; the condition of being uncertain or without conviction. — 不确定性 about what those benefits are worth. Criticscritic: One who criticizes; a person who finds fault. — 批评者;挑剔的人, however, see this as a quiet way to water down: to weaken something (usually a rule or statement) by making it less strict — 削弱 / 打折扣 regulationregulation: The act of regulating or the condition of being regulated. — 监管. As the old saying goes, what is not counted does not count.
The American government has required this kind of analysis since 1981, when President Ronald Reagan ordered federalfederal: Pertaining to the national government level in a federal nation, as opposed to state, provincial, county, city, or town. — 联邦的 agenciesagency: A department or other administrative unit of a government; also, the office or headquarters of, or the district administered by, such unit of government. — (政府)机构;局 to weigh the costs of new rules against their benefits. His aim was to cut red tape: excessive bureaucratic rules and procedures that slow things down — 繁文缛节 / 官僚程序 that, in his view, cost businesses more than it was worth. If a pollution rule saved only a few lives but spent a great deal of money, the argument went, the same money might save more lives elsewhereelsewhere: Synonym of somewhere else: in, at, or to some other place. — 在别处;到别处 — fundingfunding: The action of the verb fund. — 资助;提供资金 hospitals, for example. Critics replied that no honest number could be placed on a human life. Oddly, today’s EPA sounds rather like those critics from forty years ago.
Earlier economistseconomist: An expert in economics, especially one who studies economic data and extracts higher-level information or proposes theories. — 经济学家 had tried to solve the problem with what became known as the human-capital method: an older approach that priced a person's life as their remaining lifetime earnings, later rejected because it assigned zero value to non-earners — 人力资本法. A person’s life, they suggested, could be valued at the wageswage: An amount of money paid to a worker for a specified quantity of work, usually calculated on an hourly basis and expressed in an amount of money per hour. — 工资 they would have earned if they had lived. Wages, after all, roughlyroughly: Without precision or exactness; imprecisely but close to in quantity or amount; approximately. — 大约;大致 show what people are willingwilling: Ready to do something, particularly something that requires change or effort; not objecting. — 愿意的;乐意的 to accept for the hours of their working lives. The approachapproach: A manner of making (a policy) or solving (a problem, etc.). — 方法;途径 was eventually rejected, because it gave a value of zero to anyone without a paid job — retired people, the sick, and parents caring for children at home. Lifetimelifetime: The duration of the life of someone or something. — 一生;终生 earningsearnings: Business profits. — 收益;利润, it turned out, are not the same as a lifetime’s value.
A better idea came from Thomas Schelling, who later won a Nobel prize in economicseconomics: Chiefly with a descriptive word: the application of this study to a particular domain. — (某领域的)经济学. Schelling pointed out that we all take small risks of dying every day. Driving a car, for example, carries some chance of a fatalfatal: Causing death or destruction. — 致命的;毁灭性的 crash, and spending a little more on safety features lowerslower: To reduce the degree, intensity, strength, etc., of. — 降低(程度);减弱 that chance. By measuring how much people are willing to pay to reduce their risk of death by a tiny amount, economists can work out a figure called the value of a statisticalstatistical: Of or pertaining to statistics. — 统计的 life. If 100,000 people each pay $100 to avoid a one-in-100,000 chance of dying, then $10 million has effectively been spent to prevent one expected death. The figure does not say what a life is worth; it shows what people will pay to protect it. The EPA itself has long used a figure of around twelve million dollars per statistical life.
None of these methods give a perfect answer, and perhaps no method ever will. Yet the value of a life is clearly not zero. People generally want to stay alive, and they are willing to pay something to do so. Regulatorsregulator: A person or group that sets standards of practice, especially regulatory law as sanctioned by statutory law. — 监管机构 need a benchmarkbenchmark: A standard by which something is evaluated or measured. — 基准;标准, even an imperfectimperfect: Not perfect. — 不完美的 one, against which the costs of their decisions can be measured. Economists are sometimes accusedaccuse: To find fault with, blame, censure. — 指责;责备 of cold-heartedness for asking how much a life is worth. Refusing to ask the question, however, would be far worse.
Questions
Check your understanding
- 01
According to the article, why did the EPA say it would stop putting a price on the health benefits of cleaner air?
- 02
Why did economists eventually reject the human-capital method?
- 03
Which sentence best captures the article's main argument?
- 04
Explain why the writer suggests that today's EPA "sounds rather like" the critics of Reagan's 1981 order. What is similar about the two positions?
Suggested length: ~80 words
- 05
Evaluate Thomas Schelling's idea of the "value of a statistical life". What does it measure well, and what does it leave out?
Suggested length: ~80 words
Questions
Check your understanding
- 01
According to the article, why did the EPA say it would stop putting a price on the health benefits of cleaner air?
- 02
Why did economists eventually reject the human-capital method?
- 03
Which sentence best captures the article's main argument?
- 04
Explain why the writer suggests that today's EPA "sounds rather like" the critics of Reagan's 1981 order. What is similar about the two positions?
Suggested length: ~80 words
- 05
Evaluate Thomas Schelling's idea of the "value of a statistical life". What does it measure well, and what does it leave out?
Suggested length: ~80 words