Teacher's Note

Why read this: This piece asks a question students often dismiss out of hand — can a life be priced? — and refuses the easy answer. The article walks through four overlapping tools (cost-benefit analysis, the human-capital method, the value of a statistical life, and quality-adjusted life years), exposes the flaw in each, and then defends the most uncomfortable of them as the least-bad option. For Mandarin L1 readers, it is a chance to see an English editorial argue against its opening gut reaction, weave US political history into a methodological thread, and arrive at a thesis delivered as quiet contrast rather than direct claim. The reward is a model of how nuanced policy journalism actually moves.

What to notice: Students should track the chain of methods rather than the surface debate. Each paragraph names a flaw in the previous approach — non-earners priced at zero, identified versus statistical lives, quality-of-life weighting — and the argument's force depends on holding the chain in mind. Tonal shifts also matter: the opening clifftop image and the closing 'warmer-sounding option' are deliberately ironic, and a literal reading inverts the thesis. Watch the em-dash parentheticals; they carry content, not decoration. Note finally how the article positions the EPA's current refusal as a near-mirror of a 1980s Democratic objection — the cross-partisan irony is part of what the writing rewards.

Skills practised: Sustained argument tracking across a multi-step methodological chain; reading historical-political context (Reagan, Weidenbaum, Schelling) as load-bearing rather than decorative; parsing em-dash parentheticals for substantive content; recognising tonal irony in formal journalism; and resisting the temptation to settle on the article's opening intuition before its closing reversal. Vocabulary work centres on register-shifting items — ghoulish, ledger, adage, squint, ploy, eschew, squeamish, efficacious — and on a small but load-bearing set of economic terms: cost-benefit analysis, deregulation, mortality, utility, signing bonus. The closing skill is the hardest: stating the thesis in one sentence.

Level: Upper C1 · Length: ~710 words · Reading time: ~4 min
Graded ReadingC1

How to put a price on a human life

As ghoulish as it sounds, it is far better than the alternative

~4 min read·

Tap any green word in the article to see its meaning.

Pause on a clifftop: The top of a cliff. — 崖顶, fill your lungs with cold Atlantic air, and the breath can feel restorative: Serving to restore. — 恢复元气的, almost priceless. Cleaning the air the rest of us breathe is anything but free: factories retrofit: To add or substitute (new components or parts) that were not previously available for or installed in a device, structure, etc. — 加装;补装 scrubber: A soft and flexible handheld polymer-fiber implement for scrubbing tasks. — 百洁布;刷洗用具, dirty industries shrink: To become smaller; to contract. — 缩小;萎缩, households swap coal for cleaner fuels. On the other side of the ledger: A book or other scheme for keeping accounting records. — 账簿;分类账 sit fewer asthmatic: Having the characteristics of asthma. — 哮喘的 children and fewer hospitalisation: The hospitalizing of a patient, the condition of being hospitalized, or the period a patient stays in hospital. — 住院;住院治疗 among the old and the already ill. cost-benefit analysis: an economic method that compares the money spent on something with the benefits gained, to decide if it is worth doing — 成本效益分析 demands a number on both sides; so how do you attach one to a death not yet suffered?

America's Environmental Protection Agency has decided it would rather not. Last month the EPA announced that, in assessing future rules, it will no longer assign a monetary: Of, pertaining to, or consisting of money. — 货币的 value to clean-air health benefits, citing irreducible: Not able to be reduced or lessened. — 不可减少的 uncertainty in the figures. skeptic: Someone who doubts beliefs, claims, plans, etc. that are accepted by others as true or appropriate, especially one who habitually does so. — 怀疑者 read the move as a quiet attempt to water down: to weaken something (usually a rule or statement) by making it less strict — 削弱 / 打折扣 regulation by stealth: as the adage: An old saying which has obtained credit by long use. — 格言 goes, what is not counted does not count, and refusing to grapple with a number is itself a way of discounting it to zero. squint: To look with the eyes partly closed, as in bright sunlight, or as a threatening expression. — 眯眼看 at the announcement and a ghoulish: Fascinated by corpses; morbid. — 病态的;嗜好恐怖的 irony: Contradiction between circumstances and expectations; condition contrary to what might be expected. — 讽刺;反讽 emerges — the agency's reasoning: The deduction of inferences or interpretations from premises, abstract thought, ratiocination; (countable) any instance of this, especially as a process leading to an action, motive. — 推理;论证 now echo: To repeat (another’s speech, opinion, etc.). — 附和;重复 the very objection: A statement expressing opposition, or a reason or cause for expressing opposition (generally followed by the adposition to). — 反对;异议 once raised against pricing exercises altogether.

The pricing exercise dates back to a 1981 executive order signed by Ronald Reagan, whose aim was to cut red tape: excessive bureaucratic rules and procedures that slow things down — 繁文缛节 / 官僚程序 whose costs could not be clearly justified by its benefits. Murray Weidenbaum, then chairing his Council of Economic Advisers, argued that money lavish: To give out extremely generously; to squander. — 挥霍;滥用 on rules saving only a handful: A small number, usually approximately five. — 少数;一小撮 of lives might fund better cardiac: Pertaining to the heart. — 心脏的 ward: A part of a hospital, with beds, where patients reside. — 病房. Democratic critics, sensing a ploy: A tactic, strategy, or scheme. — 计策;花招 to dress up deregulation: The process of removing constraints, especially government-imposed economic regulation. — 放松管制 as analytical: Of or pertaining to analysis; resolving into elements or constituent parts — 分析的 rigour: Severity or strictness. — 严谨, retort: To say something sharp or witty in answer to a remark or accusation. — 反驳 that no life could be reduced to a dollar figure. Four decades on, that protest reappears almost word for word in the mouth of an environmental regulator: A person or group that sets standards of practice, especially regulatory law as sanctioned by statutory law. — 监管机构.

The EPA of the 1980s reached instead for the value of a statistical life — a figure quite distinct from any individual's worth. An earlier attempt, the human-capital method: an older approach that priced a person's life as their remaining lifetime earnings, later rejected because it assigned zero value to non-earners — 人力资本法, drew on actuarial: Of or pertaining to actuaries. — 精算师的 habits, multiplying expected wages by the working years still ahead. Wages, the reasoning ran, are the price at which someone sells their finite: Having an end or limit; (of a quantity) constrained by bounds; (of a set) whose number of elements is a natural number. — 有限的 hours; scale them across a lifetime and a market value emerges. The approach fell out of favour: stopped being popular or widely used — 失宠 / 不再受欢迎 once economists noticed its corollary: A proposition which follows easily from the statement or proof of another proposition. — 推论: anyone without a wage — the elderly, the chronically: In a chronic manner, or to a chronic degree. — 长期地 sick, parents who eschew: To avoid; to shun, to shy away from. — 避免;回避 paid work to raise children — was implicitly priced at zero.

Thomas Schelling, who took the 2005 Nobel in economics, diagnosed the deeper problem: valuation: An estimation of something's worth. — 估价 depends on whose life is in view. The named child in a fundraising: The process of collecting money by requesting donations from individuals and businesses. — 筹款;募捐 appeal commands almost limitless: Without limits in extent, size, or quantity. — 无限的;无穷的 generosity: The trait of being willing to donate money, resources, or time. — 慷慨;大方 — let a six-year-old need an operation by Christmas, he wrote in 1968, and the post office will be swamp: To overwhelm; to make too busy, or overrun the capacity of. — 压垮 with coins. Ask the same donor: One who makes a donation. — 捐献者;捐赠者 for a higher tax to lower mortality: The number of deaths per given unit of population over a given period of time. — 死亡率 among an unnamed slice of the population, however, and few will open their pocketbooks: to be willing to spend money (US idiom) — 掏腰包. Yet it is precisely that anonymous: Of unknown name; whose name is withheld — 匿名的 statistical life — possibly their own — that regulatory: Of or pertaining to regulation. — 监管的 policy must learn to price.

Schelling's resolution was to read the price off choices people already make: drivers weigh a safer car against its added cost, soldiers weigh hazardous: Risky; dangerous; with the nature of a hazard. — 危险的;有风险的 postings against bigger paychecks. Observe what a population will pay to shave: To reduce in size, weight, time taken etc., usually by a small amount. — 削减;缩短 a known fraction off its risk of death, and the arithmetic does the rest. If 100,000 people each spend $100 to avoid a one-in-100,000 chance of dying, $10m has bought one expected life. The EPA's working figure — $7.4m in 2006 dollars, roughly $12m today — comes from such studies, including one tracing how US Army signing bonus: a one-off payment given to someone when they agree to take a job, often used to attract workers to difficult positions — 签约奖金 shifted with battlefield: The area where a land battle is fought, which may not necessarily be a field. — 战场 fatality: Death, especially one caused by an accident, war or disaster. — 死亡;死亡事故 rates.

Britain has been less squeamish: Averse or reluctant. — 有顾忌的 still. Its National Health Service ration: To portion out (especially during a shortage of supply); to limit access to. — 按定量分配 treatments using quality-adjusted life years, which borrow the same logic: A method of human thought that involves thinking in a linear, step-by-step manner about how a problem can be solved. Logic is the basis of many principles including the scientific method. — 逻辑 but reweight each remaining year by some measure of utility: Well-being, satisfaction, pleasure, or happiness. — 效用. A drug prolong: To lengthen in time; to extend the duration of. — 延长(时间) life in chronic: Prolonged or slow to heal. — 长期患病的 pain may earn fewer such years than a less efficacious: Effective; possessing efficacy. — 有效的;灵验的 alternative leaving the patient comfortable; all else equal, shield: To protect, to defend. — 保护 statistical children outrank: To be of a higher rank than. — 级别高于 shielding statistical pensioner: Someone who lives on a pension, especially the retirement or old age pension. — 领养老金者.

None of these methods answers the unanswerable: Not answerable; impossible to answer. — 无法回答的. Each, however, insists that the value of a life is plainly not nothing: people prefer to remain alive, and they will pay, in money and inconvenience, to stay so. regulator: A person or group that sets standards of practice, especially regulatory law as sanctioned by statutory law. — 监管机构 need a benchmark: A standard by which something is evaluated or measured. — 基准;标准 — imperfect, contested, occasionally absurd: Contrary to reason or propriety; obviously and flatly opposed to manifest truth; inconsistent with the plain dictates of common sense; logically contradictory; nonsensical; ridiculous; silly. — 荒谬的;荒唐的 — against which to weigh any decision's costs. Economists are routinely: In a routine manner, in a way that has become common or expected. — 例行地 accused of an anti-social coldness: Limited enthusiasm or affection; coolness. — 冷漠 for asking how much a life is worth; the EPA, in declining to ask, has chosen the warmer-sounding option, and also the worse one.

Questions

Check your understanding

  1. 01

    Why does the article suggest the EPA's recent decision is ironic?

  2. 02

    What is the central distinction Schelling draws between an 'identified life' and a 'statistical life'?

  3. 03

    What does the closing line — that the EPA has chosen 'the warmer-sounding option' but also 'the worse one' — imply about the article's overall argument?

  4. 04

    Argue whether the EPA is right to abandon a monetary figure for the health benefits of clean air, drawing on at least two specific points the article makes.

    Suggested length: ~100 words

  5. 05

    Assess the claim that the value of a statistical life, derived from wages or signing bonuses, gives regulators a defensible figure for human life.

    Suggested length: ~100 words