Why read this: This piece asks a question students often dismiss out of hand — can a life be priced? — and refuses the easy answer. The article walks through four overlapping tools (cost-benefit analysis, the human-capital method, the value of a statistical life, and quality-adjusted life years), exposes the flaw in each, and then defends the most uncomfortable of them as the least-bad option. For Mandarin L1 readers, it is a chance to see an English editorial argue against its opening gut reaction, weave US political history into a methodological thread, and arrive at a thesis delivered as quiet contrast rather than direct claim. The reward is a model of how nuanced policy journalism actually moves.
What to notice: Students should track the chain of methods rather than the surface debate. Each paragraph names a flaw in the previous approach — non-earners priced at zero, identified versus statistical lives, quality-of-life weighting — and the argument's force depends on holding the chain in mind. Tonal shifts also matter: the opening clifftop image and the closing 'warmer-sounding option' are deliberately ironic, and a literal reading inverts the thesis. Watch the em-dash parentheticals; they carry content, not decoration. Note finally how the article positions the EPA's current refusal as a near-mirror of a 1980s Democratic objection — the cross-partisan irony is part of what the writing rewards.
Skills practised: Sustained argument tracking across a multi-step methodological chain; reading historical-political context (Reagan, Weidenbaum, Schelling) as load-bearing rather than decorative; parsing em-dash parentheticals for substantive content; recognising tonal irony in formal journalism; and resisting the temptation to settle on the article's opening intuition before its closing reversal. Vocabulary work centres on register-shifting items — ghoulish, ledger, adage, squint, ploy, eschew, squeamish, efficacious — and on a small but load-bearing set of economic terms: cost-benefit analysis, deregulation, mortality, utility, signing bonus. The closing skill is the hardest: stating the thesis in one sentence.
How to put a price on a human life
As ghoulish as it sounds, it is far better than the alternative
Tap any green word in the article to see its meaning.
Pause on a clifftopclifftop: The top of a cliff. — 崖顶, fill your lungs with cold Atlantic air, and the breath can feel restorativerestorative: Serving to restore. — 恢复元气的, almost priceless. Cleaning the air the rest of us breathe is anything but free: factories retrofitretrofit: To add or substitute (new components or parts) that were not previously available for or installed in a device, structure, etc. — 加装;补装 scrubbersscrubber: A soft and flexible handheld polymer-fiber implement for scrubbing tasks. — 百洁布;刷洗用具, dirty industries shrinkshrink: To become smaller; to contract. — 缩小;萎缩, households swap coal for cleaner fuels. On the other side of the ledgerledger: A book or other scheme for keeping accounting records. — 账簿;分类账 sit fewer asthmaticasthmatic: Having the characteristics of asthma. — 哮喘的 children and fewer hospitalisationshospitalisation: The hospitalizing of a patient, the condition of being hospitalized, or the period a patient stays in hospital. — 住院;住院治疗 among the old and the already ill. cost-benefit analysis: an economic method that compares the money spent on something with the benefits gained, to decide if it is worth doing — 成本效益分析 demands a number on both sides; so how do you attach one to a death not yet suffered?
America's Environmental Protection Agency has decided it would rather not. Last month the EPA announced that, in assessing future rules, it will no longer assign a monetarymonetary: Of, pertaining to, or consisting of money. — 货币的 value to clean-air health benefits, citing irreducibleirreducible: Not able to be reduced or lessened. — 不可减少的 uncertainty in the figures. Scepticsskeptic: Someone who doubts beliefs, claims, plans, etc. that are accepted by others as true or appropriate, especially one who habitually does so. — 怀疑者 read the move as a quiet attempt to water down: to weaken something (usually a rule or statement) by making it less strict — 削弱 / 打折扣 regulation by stealth: as the adageadage: An old saying which has obtained credit by long use. — 格言 goes, what is not counted does not count, and refusing to grapple with a number is itself a way of discounting it to zero. Squintsquint: To look with the eyes partly closed, as in bright sunlight, or as a threatening expression. — 眯眼看 at the announcement and a ghoulishghoulish: Fascinated by corpses; morbid. — 病态的;嗜好恐怖的 ironyirony: Contradiction between circumstances and expectations; condition contrary to what might be expected. — 讽刺;反讽 emerges — the agency's reasoningreasoning: The deduction of inferences or interpretations from premises, abstract thought, ratiocination; (countable) any instance of this, especially as a process leading to an action, motive. — 推理;论证 now echoesecho: To repeat (another’s speech, opinion, etc.). — 附和;重复 the very objectionsobjection: A statement expressing opposition, or a reason or cause for expressing opposition (generally followed by the adposition to). — 反对;异议 once raised against pricing exercises altogether.
The pricing exercise dates back to a 1981 executive order signed by Ronald Reagan, whose aim was to cut red tape: excessive bureaucratic rules and procedures that slow things down — 繁文缛节 / 官僚程序 whose costs could not be clearly justified by its benefits. Murray Weidenbaum, then chairing his Council of Economic Advisers, argued that money lavishedlavish: To give out extremely generously; to squander. — 挥霍;滥用 on rules saving only a handfulhandful: A small number, usually approximately five. — 少数;一小撮 of lives might fund better cardiaccardiac: Pertaining to the heart. — 心脏的 wardsward: A part of a hospital, with beds, where patients reside. — 病房. Democratic critics, sensing a ployploy: A tactic, strategy, or scheme. — 计策;花招 to dress up deregulationderegulation: The process of removing constraints, especially government-imposed economic regulation. — 放松管制 as analyticalanalytical: Of or pertaining to analysis; resolving into elements or constituent parts — 分析的 rigourrigour: Severity or strictness. — 严谨, retortedretort: To say something sharp or witty in answer to a remark or accusation. — 反驳 that no life could be reduced to a dollar figure. Four decades on, that protest reappears almost word for word in the mouth of an environmental regulatorregulator: A person or group that sets standards of practice, especially regulatory law as sanctioned by statutory law. — 监管机构.
The EPA of the 1980s reached instead for the value of a statistical life — a figure quite distinct from any individual's worth. An earlier attempt, the human-capital method: an older approach that priced a person's life as their remaining lifetime earnings, later rejected because it assigned zero value to non-earners — 人力资本法, drew on actuarialactuarial: Of or pertaining to actuaries. — 精算师的 habits, multiplying expected wages by the working years still ahead. Wages, the reasoning ran, are the price at which someone sells their finitefinite: Having an end or limit; (of a quantity) constrained by bounds; (of a set) whose number of elements is a natural number. — 有限的 hours; scale them across a lifetime and a market value emerges. The approach fell out of favour: stopped being popular or widely used — 失宠 / 不再受欢迎 once economists noticed its corollarycorollary: A proposition which follows easily from the statement or proof of another proposition. — 推论: anyone without a wage — the elderly, the chronicallychronically: In a chronic manner, or to a chronic degree. — 长期地 sick, parents who escheweschew: To avoid; to shun, to shy away from. — 避免;回避 paid work to raise children — was implicitly priced at zero.
Thomas Schelling, who took the 2005 Nobel in economics, diagnosed the deeper problem: valuationvaluation: An estimation of something's worth. — 估价 depends on whose life is in view. The named child in a fundraisingfundraising: The process of collecting money by requesting donations from individuals and businesses. — 筹款;募捐 appeal commands almost limitlesslimitless: Without limits in extent, size, or quantity. — 无限的;无穷的 generositygenerosity: The trait of being willing to donate money, resources, or time. — 慷慨;大方 — let a six-year-old need an operation by Christmas, he wrote in 1968, and the post office will be swampedswamp: To overwhelm; to make too busy, or overrun the capacity of. — 压垮 with coins. Ask the same donorsdonor: One who makes a donation. — 捐献者;捐赠者 for a higher tax to lower mortalitymortality: The number of deaths per given unit of population over a given period of time. — 死亡率 among an unnamed slice of the population, however, and few will open their pocketbooks: to be willing to spend money (US idiom) — 掏腰包. Yet it is precisely that anonymousanonymous: Of unknown name; whose name is withheld — 匿名的 statistical life — possibly their own — that regulatoryregulatory: Of or pertaining to regulation. — 监管的 policy must learn to price.
Schelling's resolution was to read the price off choices people already make: drivers weigh a safer car against its added cost, soldiers weigh hazardoushazardous: Risky; dangerous; with the nature of a hazard. — 危险的;有风险的 postings against bigger paychecks. Observe what a population will pay to shaveshave: To reduce in size, weight, time taken etc., usually by a small amount. — 削减;缩短 a known fraction off its risk of death, and the arithmetic does the rest. If 100,000 people each spend $100 to avoid a one-in-100,000 chance of dying, $10m has bought one expected life. The EPA's working figure — $7.4m in 2006 dollars, roughly $12m today — comes from such studies, including one tracing how US Army signing bonus: a one-off payment given to someone when they agree to take a job, often used to attract workers to difficult positions — 签约奖金 shifted with battlefieldbattlefield: The area where a land battle is fought, which may not necessarily be a field. — 战场 fatalityfatality: Death, especially one caused by an accident, war or disaster. — 死亡;死亡事故 rates.
Britain has been less squeamishsqueamish: Averse or reluctant. — 有顾忌的 still. Its National Health Service rationsration: To portion out (especially during a shortage of supply); to limit access to. — 按定量分配 treatments using quality-adjusted life years, which borrow the same logiclogic: A method of human thought that involves thinking in a linear, step-by-step manner about how a problem can be solved. Logic is the basis of many principles including the scientific method. — 逻辑 but reweight each remaining year by some measure of utilityutility: Well-being, satisfaction, pleasure, or happiness. — 效用. A drug prolongingprolong: To lengthen in time; to extend the duration of. — 延长(时间) life in chronicchronic: Prolonged or slow to heal. — 长期患病的 pain may earn fewer such years than a less efficaciousefficacious: Effective; possessing efficacy. — 有效的;灵验的 alternative leaving the patient comfortable; all else equal, shieldingshield: To protect, to defend. — 保护 statistical children outranksoutrank: To be of a higher rank than. — 级别高于 shielding statistical pensionerspensioner: Someone who lives on a pension, especially the retirement or old age pension. — 领养老金者.
None of these methods answers the unanswerableunanswerable: Not answerable; impossible to answer. — 无法回答的. Each, however, insists that the value of a life is plainly not nothing: people prefer to remain alive, and they will pay, in money and inconvenience, to stay so. Regulatorsregulator: A person or group that sets standards of practice, especially regulatory law as sanctioned by statutory law. — 监管机构 need a benchmarkbenchmark: A standard by which something is evaluated or measured. — 基准;标准 — imperfect, contested, occasionally absurdabsurd: Contrary to reason or propriety; obviously and flatly opposed to manifest truth; inconsistent with the plain dictates of common sense; logically contradictory; nonsensical; ridiculous; silly. — 荒谬的;荒唐的 — against which to weigh any decision's costs. Economists are routinelyroutinely: In a routine manner, in a way that has become common or expected. — 例行地 accused of an anti-social coldnesscoldness: Limited enthusiasm or affection; coolness. — 冷漠 for asking how much a life is worth; the EPA, in declining to ask, has chosen the warmer-sounding option, and also the worse one.
Pause on a clifftopclifftop: The top of a cliff. — 崖顶, fill your lungs with cold Atlantic air, and the breath can feel restorativerestorative: Serving to restore. — 恢复元气的, almost priceless. Cleaning the air the rest of us breathe is anything but free: factories retrofitretrofit: To add or substitute (new components or parts) that were not previously available for or installed in a device, structure, etc. — 加装;补装 scrubbersscrubber: A soft and flexible handheld polymer-fiber implement for scrubbing tasks. — 百洁布;刷洗用具, dirty industries shrinkshrink: To become smaller; to contract. — 缩小;萎缩, households swap coal for cleaner fuels. On the other side of the ledgerledger: A book or other scheme for keeping accounting records. — 账簿;分类账 sit fewer asthmaticasthmatic: Having the characteristics of asthma. — 哮喘的 children and fewer hospitalisationshospitalisation: The hospitalizing of a patient, the condition of being hospitalized, or the period a patient stays in hospital. — 住院;住院治疗 among the old and the already ill. cost-benefit analysis: an economic method that compares the money spent on something with the benefits gained, to decide if it is worth doing — 成本效益分析 demands a number on both sides; so how do you attach one to a death not yet suffered?
America's Environmental Protection Agency has decided it would rather not. Last month the EPA announced that, in assessing future rules, it will no longer assign a monetarymonetary: Of, pertaining to, or consisting of money. — 货币的 value to clean-air health benefits, citing irreducibleirreducible: Not able to be reduced or lessened. — 不可减少的 uncertainty in the figures. Scepticsskeptic: Someone who doubts beliefs, claims, plans, etc. that are accepted by others as true or appropriate, especially one who habitually does so. — 怀疑者 read the move as a quiet attempt to water down: to weaken something (usually a rule or statement) by making it less strict — 削弱 / 打折扣 regulation by stealth: as the adageadage: An old saying which has obtained credit by long use. — 格言 goes, what is not counted does not count, and refusing to grapple with a number is itself a way of discounting it to zero. Squintsquint: To look with the eyes partly closed, as in bright sunlight, or as a threatening expression. — 眯眼看 at the announcement and a ghoulishghoulish: Fascinated by corpses; morbid. — 病态的;嗜好恐怖的 ironyirony: Contradiction between circumstances and expectations; condition contrary to what might be expected. — 讽刺;反讽 emerges — the agency's reasoningreasoning: The deduction of inferences or interpretations from premises, abstract thought, ratiocination; (countable) any instance of this, especially as a process leading to an action, motive. — 推理;论证 now echoesecho: To repeat (another’s speech, opinion, etc.). — 附和;重复 the very objectionsobjection: A statement expressing opposition, or a reason or cause for expressing opposition (generally followed by the adposition to). — 反对;异议 once raised against pricing exercises altogether.
The pricing exercise dates back to a 1981 executive order signed by Ronald Reagan, whose aim was to cut red tape: excessive bureaucratic rules and procedures that slow things down — 繁文缛节 / 官僚程序 whose costs could not be clearly justified by its benefits. Murray Weidenbaum, then chairing his Council of Economic Advisers, argued that money lavishedlavish: To give out extremely generously; to squander. — 挥霍;滥用 on rules saving only a handfulhandful: A small number, usually approximately five. — 少数;一小撮 of lives might fund better cardiaccardiac: Pertaining to the heart. — 心脏的 wardsward: A part of a hospital, with beds, where patients reside. — 病房. Democratic critics, sensing a ployploy: A tactic, strategy, or scheme. — 计策;花招 to dress up deregulationderegulation: The process of removing constraints, especially government-imposed economic regulation. — 放松管制 as analyticalanalytical: Of or pertaining to analysis; resolving into elements or constituent parts — 分析的 rigourrigour: Severity or strictness. — 严谨, retortedretort: To say something sharp or witty in answer to a remark or accusation. — 反驳 that no life could be reduced to a dollar figure. Four decades on, that protest reappears almost word for word in the mouth of an environmental regulatorregulator: A person or group that sets standards of practice, especially regulatory law as sanctioned by statutory law. — 监管机构.
The EPA of the 1980s reached instead for the value of a statistical life — a figure quite distinct from any individual's worth. An earlier attempt, the human-capital method: an older approach that priced a person's life as their remaining lifetime earnings, later rejected because it assigned zero value to non-earners — 人力资本法, drew on actuarialactuarial: Of or pertaining to actuaries. — 精算师的 habits, multiplying expected wages by the working years still ahead. Wages, the reasoning ran, are the price at which someone sells their finitefinite: Having an end or limit; (of a quantity) constrained by bounds; (of a set) whose number of elements is a natural number. — 有限的 hours; scale them across a lifetime and a market value emerges. The approach fell out of favour: stopped being popular or widely used — 失宠 / 不再受欢迎 once economists noticed its corollarycorollary: A proposition which follows easily from the statement or proof of another proposition. — 推论: anyone without a wage — the elderly, the chronicallychronically: In a chronic manner, or to a chronic degree. — 长期地 sick, parents who escheweschew: To avoid; to shun, to shy away from. — 避免;回避 paid work to raise children — was implicitly priced at zero.
Thomas Schelling, who took the 2005 Nobel in economics, diagnosed the deeper problem: valuationvaluation: An estimation of something's worth. — 估价 depends on whose life is in view. The named child in a fundraisingfundraising: The process of collecting money by requesting donations from individuals and businesses. — 筹款;募捐 appeal commands almost limitlesslimitless: Without limits in extent, size, or quantity. — 无限的;无穷的 generositygenerosity: The trait of being willing to donate money, resources, or time. — 慷慨;大方 — let a six-year-old need an operation by Christmas, he wrote in 1968, and the post office will be swampedswamp: To overwhelm; to make too busy, or overrun the capacity of. — 压垮 with coins. Ask the same donorsdonor: One who makes a donation. — 捐献者;捐赠者 for a higher tax to lower mortalitymortality: The number of deaths per given unit of population over a given period of time. — 死亡率 among an unnamed slice of the population, however, and few will open their pocketbooks: to be willing to spend money (US idiom) — 掏腰包. Yet it is precisely that anonymousanonymous: Of unknown name; whose name is withheld — 匿名的 statistical life — possibly their own — that regulatoryregulatory: Of or pertaining to regulation. — 监管的 policy must learn to price.
Schelling's resolution was to read the price off choices people already make: drivers weigh a safer car against its added cost, soldiers weigh hazardoushazardous: Risky; dangerous; with the nature of a hazard. — 危险的;有风险的 postings against bigger paychecks. Observe what a population will pay to shaveshave: To reduce in size, weight, time taken etc., usually by a small amount. — 削减;缩短 a known fraction off its risk of death, and the arithmetic does the rest. If 100,000 people each spend $100 to avoid a one-in-100,000 chance of dying, $10m has bought one expected life. The EPA's working figure — $7.4m in 2006 dollars, roughly $12m today — comes from such studies, including one tracing how US Army signing bonus: a one-off payment given to someone when they agree to take a job, often used to attract workers to difficult positions — 签约奖金 shifted with battlefieldbattlefield: The area where a land battle is fought, which may not necessarily be a field. — 战场 fatalityfatality: Death, especially one caused by an accident, war or disaster. — 死亡;死亡事故 rates.
Britain has been less squeamishsqueamish: Averse or reluctant. — 有顾忌的 still. Its National Health Service rationsration: To portion out (especially during a shortage of supply); to limit access to. — 按定量分配 treatments using quality-adjusted life years, which borrow the same logiclogic: A method of human thought that involves thinking in a linear, step-by-step manner about how a problem can be solved. Logic is the basis of many principles including the scientific method. — 逻辑 but reweight each remaining year by some measure of utilityutility: Well-being, satisfaction, pleasure, or happiness. — 效用. A drug prolongingprolong: To lengthen in time; to extend the duration of. — 延长(时间) life in chronicchronic: Prolonged or slow to heal. — 长期患病的 pain may earn fewer such years than a less efficaciousefficacious: Effective; possessing efficacy. — 有效的;灵验的 alternative leaving the patient comfortable; all else equal, shieldingshield: To protect, to defend. — 保护 statistical children outranksoutrank: To be of a higher rank than. — 级别高于 shielding statistical pensionerspensioner: Someone who lives on a pension, especially the retirement or old age pension. — 领养老金者.
None of these methods answers the unanswerableunanswerable: Not answerable; impossible to answer. — 无法回答的. Each, however, insists that the value of a life is plainly not nothing: people prefer to remain alive, and they will pay, in money and inconvenience, to stay so. Regulatorsregulator: A person or group that sets standards of practice, especially regulatory law as sanctioned by statutory law. — 监管机构 need a benchmarkbenchmark: A standard by which something is evaluated or measured. — 基准;标准 — imperfect, contested, occasionally absurdabsurd: Contrary to reason or propriety; obviously and flatly opposed to manifest truth; inconsistent with the plain dictates of common sense; logically contradictory; nonsensical; ridiculous; silly. — 荒谬的;荒唐的 — against which to weigh any decision's costs. Economists are routinelyroutinely: In a routine manner, in a way that has become common or expected. — 例行地 accused of an anti-social coldnesscoldness: Limited enthusiasm or affection; coolness. — 冷漠 for asking how much a life is worth; the EPA, in declining to ask, has chosen the warmer-sounding option, and also the worse one.
Questions
Check your understanding
- 01
Why does the article suggest the EPA's recent decision is ironic?
- 02
What is the central distinction Schelling draws between an 'identified life' and a 'statistical life'?
- 03
What does the closing line — that the EPA has chosen 'the warmer-sounding option' but also 'the worse one' — imply about the article's overall argument?
- 04
Argue whether the EPA is right to abandon a monetary figure for the health benefits of clean air, drawing on at least two specific points the article makes.
Suggested length: ~100 words
- 05
Assess the claim that the value of a statistical life, derived from wages or signing bonuses, gives regulators a defensible figure for human life.
Suggested length: ~100 words
Questions
Check your understanding
- 01
Why does the article suggest the EPA's recent decision is ironic?
- 02
What is the central distinction Schelling draws between an 'identified life' and a 'statistical life'?
- 03
What does the closing line — that the EPA has chosen 'the warmer-sounding option' but also 'the worse one' — imply about the article's overall argument?
- 04
Argue whether the EPA is right to abandon a monetary figure for the health benefits of clean air, drawing on at least two specific points the article makes.
Suggested length: ~100 words
- 05
Assess the claim that the value of a statistical life, derived from wages or signing bonuses, gives regulators a defensible figure for human life.
Suggested length: ~100 words