Why read this: This short article asks a hard question in simple words: how much is a life worth? Students at A2 can read it without help. The article shows them that big choices in real life often need numbers, even when numbers feel strange. It also helps them think about clean air, a topic many of them already care about.
What to notice: Notice the way the article puts two sides next to each other. On one side: the cost of new rules. On the other side: the lives saved. This is the main idea. Also notice the word 'but' at the start of some sentences. It shows a change in the idea. The last paragraph is short and clear. It tells the reader what the writer thinks.
Skills practised: Students practise reading short sentences and joining them into one big idea. They learn one new term: cost-benefit analysis. They also practise saying their own view, using simple words. The open questions ask them to list and describe, not to argue. This is the right skill at A2.
How much is a human life worth?
It sounds cold to ask. But not asking is worse.
Tap any green word in the article to see its meaning.
How much is fresh air worthworth: Having a value of; proper to be exchanged for. — 值…的? Many people would say it has no price. But governmentsgovernment: The body with the power to make and/or enforce laws to control a country, land area, people or organization. — 政府 have to decide how much money to spend on clean air. New rules cost money. Factoriesfactory: A building or other place where manufacturing takes place. — 工厂 must buy new machinesmachine: A device that directs and controls energy, often in the form of movement or electricity, to produce a certain effect. — 机器. Some old jobs may end. So we need to ask: how much is clean air worth to us?
This is part of a bigger problem. When the air is dirty, more people get sick. Some children get sick. Some old people die early. So clean air savessave: To help (somebody) to survive, or rescue (somebody or something) from harm. — 救;挽救 lives. To choose the right rules, we must compare two things. On one sideside: One half (left or right, top or bottom, front or back, etc.) of something or someone. — 边;侧 is the money we spend. On the other side is the valuevalue: The quality that renders something desirable or valuable; worth. — 价值 of the lives we savesave: To help (somebody) to survive, or rescue (somebody or something) from harm. — 救;挽救. This way of thinkingthinking: The action or process of using one's mind to consider or reason about something. — 思考;思维 is called cost-benefit analysis: a way of choosing what to do by comparing the money it costs with the good things it brings — 成本效益分析.
But here is the hard part. How much is one life worth? Most people say a life cannot have a price. A life is too important. But if we say a life is worth nothing, then no rule will ever passpass: To go past, by, over, or through; to proceed from one side to the other of; to move past. — 经过;通过. The cost will always look too high. So someone has to pick a number, eveneven: In reality (used to imply an extreme example in the case mentioned). — 甚至;竟然 if the number feels strangestrange: Not normal; odd, unusual, surprising, out of the ordinary, often with a negative connotation. — 奇怪的;不寻常的.
So how do expertsexpert: A person with extensive knowledge or ability in a given subject. — 专家;能手 pick a number? They look at small choiceschoice: One selection or preference; that which is chosen or decided; the outcome of a decision. — 选择;选中的东西. For example, a safersafe: Not in danger; out of harm's reach. — 安全的 car costs more money. People pay extra to lowerlower: To reduce the degree, intensity, strength, etc., of. — 降低(程度);减弱 their riskrisk: The probability of a negative outcome to a decision or event. — 风险;危险 of deathdeath: The cessation of life and all associated processes; the end of an organism's existence as an entity independent from its environment and its return to an inert, non-living state. — 死亡;死去. From these choices, experts work out a number. In America, one common number is about 12 million dollars perper: For each. — 每 life. This number is not what one person is worth. It only helps make rules.
Some people say this is cold. They think it is wrong to put a number on a life. But if we never try, we cannot make good rules. A roughrough: Approximate; hasty or careless; not finished. — 粗略的;大致的 number is better than no number. Asking the hard question is better than not asking at all.
How much is fresh air worthworth: Having a value of; proper to be exchanged for. — 值…的? Many people would say it has no price. But governmentsgovernment: The body with the power to make and/or enforce laws to control a country, land area, people or organization. — 政府 have to decide how much money to spend on clean air. New rules cost money. Factoriesfactory: A building or other place where manufacturing takes place. — 工厂 must buy new machinesmachine: A device that directs and controls energy, often in the form of movement or electricity, to produce a certain effect. — 机器. Some old jobs may end. So we need to ask: how much is clean air worth to us?
This is part of a bigger problem. When the air is dirty, more people get sick. Some children get sick. Some old people die early. So clean air savessave: To help (somebody) to survive, or rescue (somebody or something) from harm. — 救;挽救 lives. To choose the right rules, we must compare two things. On one sideside: One half (left or right, top or bottom, front or back, etc.) of something or someone. — 边;侧 is the money we spend. On the other side is the valuevalue: The quality that renders something desirable or valuable; worth. — 价值 of the lives we savesave: To help (somebody) to survive, or rescue (somebody or something) from harm. — 救;挽救. This way of thinkingthinking: The action or process of using one's mind to consider or reason about something. — 思考;思维 is called cost-benefit analysis: a way of choosing what to do by comparing the money it costs with the good things it brings — 成本效益分析.
But here is the hard part. How much is one life worth? Most people say a life cannot have a price. A life is too important. But if we say a life is worth nothing, then no rule will ever passpass: To go past, by, over, or through; to proceed from one side to the other of; to move past. — 经过;通过. The cost will always look too high. So someone has to pick a number, eveneven: In reality (used to imply an extreme example in the case mentioned). — 甚至;竟然 if the number feels strangestrange: Not normal; odd, unusual, surprising, out of the ordinary, often with a negative connotation. — 奇怪的;不寻常的.
So how do expertsexpert: A person with extensive knowledge or ability in a given subject. — 专家;能手 pick a number? They look at small choiceschoice: One selection or preference; that which is chosen or decided; the outcome of a decision. — 选择;选中的东西. For example, a safersafe: Not in danger; out of harm's reach. — 安全的 car costs more money. People pay extra to lowerlower: To reduce the degree, intensity, strength, etc., of. — 降低(程度);减弱 their riskrisk: The probability of a negative outcome to a decision or event. — 风险;危险 of deathdeath: The cessation of life and all associated processes; the end of an organism's existence as an entity independent from its environment and its return to an inert, non-living state. — 死亡;死去. From these choices, experts work out a number. In America, one common number is about 12 million dollars perper: For each. — 每 life. This number is not what one person is worth. It only helps make rules.
Some people say this is cold. They think it is wrong to put a number on a life. But if we never try, we cannot make good rules. A roughrough: Approximate; hasty or careless; not finished. — 粗略的;大致的 number is better than no number. Asking the hard question is better than not asking at all.
Questions
Check your understanding
- 01
What does the article say about clean air rules?
- 02
How do experts pick a number for a life?
- 03
What number does America often use for one life?
- 04
Describe two costs of making clean air rules.
Suggested length: ~50 words
- 05
List two reasons why the article says it is better to pick a number for a life than to pick no number.
Suggested length: ~50 words
Questions
Check your understanding
- 01
What does the article say about clean air rules?
- 02
How do experts pick a number for a life?
- 03
What number does America often use for one life?
- 04
Describe two costs of making clean air rules.
Suggested length: ~50 words
- 05
List two reasons why the article says it is better to pick a number for a life than to pick no number.
Suggested length: ~50 words