Teacher's Note

Why read this: This B1 version keeps the three big ideas of the original article in clear, simple English. America has new food rules, and the rules say that meat, butter and beef tallow are healthy. However, these foods are full of saturated fat, which is bad for the heart. The rules also tell people to eat much more protein than they really need. The article gives students a chance to read about a real news story from 2025 and to think about whether official advice is always right. It also helps them see how a writer can disagree politely, by laying out the numbers and letting readers work out the problem.

What to notice: Ask students to notice three things. First, the picture of the upside-down pyramid in paragraph 3 is not just a picture. It puts meat, dairy products and vegetables at the top, and grains at the bottom, and this choice is part of the writer's argument. Second, in paragraph 4 the writer explains how saturated fat raises cholesterol and why this is a risk factor for heart attacks. This sentence is the heart of the article. Third, in paragraph 5 the writer adds up the numbers: one steak, three servings of dairy and a spoon of butter can already pass the daily limit. The two hedges, 'may look helpful' and 'may push you past', show that the writer is doubtful, not certain.

Skills practised: Students practise reading a short news article and finding the main idea in each paragraph. They learn to follow simple cause-and-effect chains (saturated fat raises cholesterol, and high cholesterol is a risk factor for heart attacks). They also practise reading numbers in context: the daily limit of 20 to 30 grams, and how quickly normal foods reach that limit. The article gives one signposted inference (most people do not need this much protein), so students learn to combine two facts to reach a new idea. Finally, students meet useful nutrition vocabulary, such as dietary guidelines, processed foods, dairy products, vegetable oils, body weight and balanced diet, in clear sentences.

Level: B1 · Length: ~540 words · Reading time: ~3 min
Graded Reading"B1"

"Do America's new food rules really make sense?"

"The new dietary guidelines push meat and butter, but the numbers inside the same document do not add up"

~3 min read·

Tap any green word in the article to see its meaning.

America has published new dietary guidelines: official advice from a government on what people should eat to stay healthy — 膳食指南, which appeared on January 7th, and they tell people what to eat for good health. Some nutrition: The process of providing or obtaining food necessary for health and growth. — 营养;营养学 experts are pleased with the advice, but many others are worried about it. The new advice may look helpful at first glance: A brief or hurried look at something. — 一瞥;匆匆一看. Yet if you eat what it actually says, you will easily go past the healthy limit: the greatest amount of something that is allowed or possible — 限制;限度 set: To put something in a particular place or position, or to decide on a time, amount, etc. — 设置;放置;确定 inside the same document: Any material substance on which the information is represented by writing — 文字载体,书写材料.

The general message is not new or controversial: Arousing controversy; being the subject of, or causing, a debate or argument — 引起争议的;有争论的, and it repeats what earlier guidelines and most nutritionist: An expert or specialist in nutrition or nutritionistics — 营养师 have said for many years. Eat lots of fresh fruit and vegetables, and choose foods rich in protein: A nutrient found in food such as meat, eggs, and beans that is essential for body growth and repair. — 蛋白质. Pick whole grain: a seed of wheat, rice, or other cereal plant; also cereals in general — 谷物;谷粒 rather than refined: Cultured, freed from vulgarity, particularly: — 高雅的 ones like white bread. Avoid sugary: Of food, drink, etc, containing or covered with a large amount of sugar — 含糖的 drinks and processed foods: foods that have been changed from their natural state, often with added sugar, salt, or chemicals — 加工食品 with many added chemical: Any specific chemical element or chemical compound or alloy — 化学物质 you cannot easily pronounce, and cut down on alcohol: Drinks such as beer, wine, or spirits that can make people drunk. — 酒;酒精 as well.

Many experts are angry about one big change in the new advice. The guidelines now push people to eat more meat and animal fats, including butter and beef tallow: A hard animal fat obtained from suet, etc.; used in cooking as well as to make candles, soap and lubricants — 牛脂, which they call "healthy fats". The picture next to the guidelines is an upside-down pyramid: A construction in the shape of a pyramid, usually with a square or rectangular base — 锥形结构: meat, dairy products: foods made from milk, such as cheese, yoghurt and butter — 乳制品 and vegetables sit at the top, so people should eat lots of them. Grains sit at the bottom and should be eaten only in small amounts. A fatty: Containing, composed of, or consisting of fat — 含脂肪的 steak: (by extension) A relatively large, thick slice or slab cut from another animal, a vegetable, etc — 厚切肉块, cheese, whole milk and a thick piece of butter fill most of the protein section.

The problem with this picture is simple. Fats from red meat and animal foods are mostly the saturate: Saturated; wet — 饱和的 kind, and this kind of fat raises the level of cholesterol: The level of cholesterol in the body — 胆固醇水平 in your blood. High cholesterol is a major risk factor: something that makes a bad health outcome more likely — 风险因素 for heart attacks and other heart problems. A healthier choice is unsaturated: (of a solution) Not saturated; capable of dissolving more of a solute at the same temperature — 未饱和的 fat, which is the main kind in vegetable oils: cooking oils made from plant sources rather than animal fat — 植物油. These oils come from olive: A tree, Olea europaea, cultivated since ancient times in the Mediterranean for its fruit and the oil obtained from it — 橄榄树, rapeseed: The rape plant itself — 油菜植株 (also called canola) or sunflower: A bright yellow, like that of the flower petals — 向日葵黄 seeds. RFK junior, America's health chief: The leader or head of a group, organisation, or tribe — 首领, has long: For a great amount of time — 长时间 dislike: To not like someone or something. — 不喜欢;厌恶 seed oils, and he has called them poisonous: Containing poison; capable of causing illness or death. — 有毒的. However, science does not support this claim: To say that something is true, even though it has not been proved. — 声称;宣称;索赔.

The new focus on meat and butter is also at odds with: in disagreement or conflict with — 与……相矛盾 another rule inside the guidelines. They say that people should keep their saturated fat under about 20 to 30 grams a day. One fatty steak alone may push you past that limit: the greatest amount of something that is allowed or possible — 限制;限度. Three serving: The action of the verb to serve — 服务行为 of full-fat dairy add about 15 more grams to the daily total: An amount obtained by the addition of smaller amounts — 总数. Each spoon of butter or beef tallow adds another 7 grams on top of that.

The protein target in the new guidelines is also too high for most people. The advice is to eat 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein per kilogram: The unit of weight such that a one-kilogram mass is also a one-kilogram weight — 公斤 of body weight: how much a person weighs — 体重 each day. For someone who weigh: to measure how heavy something or someone is — 称重;重达 80 kilogram: The unit of weight such that a one-kilogram mass is also a one-kilogram weight — 公斤, that means about three lean chicken breast: Either of the two soft, rounded parts on a woman's chest; the front part of a bird's body. — 乳房;胸部. A vegetarian: A person who does not eat animal flesh, or, in some cases, use any animal products — 素食者 would need 17 eggs, one kilogram of cooked beans, or 3.3 litre: A metric unit of capacity equal to 1,000 cubic centimetres. — 升;公升 of milk. Most people simply: in an easy or plain way; just; only — 简单地;仅仅 do not need this much protein, and the World Health Organisation suggests that 0.8 grams per kilogram is enough. Protein helps the body build and keep muscle: a piece of body tissue that you can tighten and relax to move parts of your body — 肌肉, so the higher amount is needed only for people who lift heavy weights at the gym.

The basic: Forming the most important or fundamental part of something; simple. — 基本的;基础的 idea behind the guidelines is still sensible: Easily perceived; appreciable. — 明智的;合情合理的 enough: eat a balanced diet: a way of eating that includes the right amounts of all kinds of food — 均衡饮食 of fresh food, cooked in a healthy way at home. But do not eat too many calorie: The gram calorie or small calorie, a non-SI unit of energy, equivalent to approximately 4.2 joules. This unit was widely used in chemistry and physics, being the amount of energy needed to raise the temperature of 1 gram of water by 1 °C — 小卡 or too much animal fat.

Questions

Check your understanding

  1. 01

    What does the writer say about the picture next to the new guidelines?

  2. 02

    Why is too much saturated fat bad for the heart?

  3. 03

    The writer suggests that for most people the protein target is too high. Which sentence best supports this idea?

  4. 04

    Explain why many nutrition experts are worried about the new American dietary guidelines.

    Suggested length: ~70 words

  5. 05

    Compare the protein target in the new guidelines with the World Health Organisation's advice. Which is better for most people, and why?

    Suggested length: ~70 words