Teacher's Note

Why read this: This article gives B2 readers a clear way into a surprising research finding: the children who train hardest rarely become world-class adults. The writer keeps the original argument but builds it from shorter sentences, friendlier vocabulary and a familiar opening (Novak Djokovic). Students get useful practice reading a multi-step argument that mixes statistics with real examples, and they meet ideas about talent, training and effort that they will recognise from school, sport and music lessons.

What to notice: Notice how the writer first sets up an expectation (the prodigy story) and then turns it on its head with the new study. Watch for the way evidence is stacked across four very different fields—sport, chess, classical music, academia—to make the conclusion feel reliable. The hardest paragraph is the long one with the 90/10 figure: pause and check that you can explain what 'negatively correlated' means in your own words. Also notice the careful, hedged ending: the writer does not say 'close the academies', only 'rethink them'.

Skills practised: Readers practise tracking a single argument across many examples, recognising cause-and-effect language, and reading numbers (34,000 performers, 90% / 10%) without losing the main thread. They also work on inference—seeing why the writer opens with Djokovic, why Nadal is mentioned, and why the closing paragraph hedges. Margin glosses cover the most domain-specific terms, including three named theories (search and match, limited-risk hypothesis, training efficiency), so cognitive room is freed up for the larger reasoning.

Level: B2 · Length: ~580 words · Reading time: ~3 min
Graded ReadingB2

Why Brilliant Children Rarely Become World-Class Adults

A new study of 34,000 top performers suggests that early stars usually fade—and the ones who reach the very top take a slower, wider path.

~3 min read·

Tap any green word in the article to see its meaning.

Novak Djokovic first picked up a tennis racket at the age of four. By twelve, he had left his home in Serbia for a tennis academy: A school or place of training in which some special art is taught. — 专科学校;学院 in Germany. He won his first major title—the 2008 Australian Open—at twenty. Today, he holds 24 major titles and has spent more time ranked number one in the world than any other player in history.

Djokovic's career fits a familiar story about human talent: a child prodigy: a young child who shows exceptional skill in a particular field — 「神童」, trained intensely from a young age, grows up to dominate: To enjoy a commanding position in some field. — 主导;支配 his field. But a new paper in the journal Science suggests he may be the exception: That which is excluded from others; a person, thing, or case, specified as distinct, or not included. — 例外, not the rule. In many fields, the very best adults followed a very different path.

The study, led by Arne Güllich, a sports scientist at RPTU University Kaiserslautern-Landau in Germany, examined data on more than 34,000 elite: Representing the choicest or most select of a group. — 精英的;顶尖的 performer: One who performs or does anything. — 执行者;做事的人 in sport, chess, classical music, and academia: The scientific and cultural community engaged in higher education and research, taken as a whole. — 学术界. The finding: A result of research or an investigation. — 调查结果;研究发现 was striking. The teenagers who trained the hardest and performed best as children rarely became true superstars as adults. The adults who did reach the top tended not to stand out early. They took longer to reach their peak: The highest value reached by some quantity in a time period. — 顶峰;高峰, and they kept a wider range of interests for longer.

The received wisdom: an opinion or belief that is widely accepted as correct — 「普遍接受的观点」—on which most sports academies are built—is that the best way to grow talent is to spot it early and drill: To practice, especially in (or as in) a military context. — 反复训练 it hard. But the research behind that idea had only looked at school and university athletes. It had not followed them into adult careers. More recent studies that did track adults all reached the same conclusion: early performance is a poor guide to adult success.

Güllich extend: To bestow; to offer; to impart; to apply. — 给予;提供 this kind of analysis to other fields. Chess was easy, because players have Elo ratings: a number system that ranks chess players' skill levels against one another — 「等级分系统」. academic: A senior member of an academy, college, or university; a person who attends an academy; a person engaged in scholarly pursuits; one who is academic in practice. — 学者;大学教师 could be ranked using citation: An entry in a list of sources from which information was taken, typically following a prescribed bibliographical style; a reference. — 引文;引用出处 database: A collection of (usually) organized information in a regular structure, usually but not necessarily in a machine-readable format accessible by a computer. — 数据库 and prize: An honour or reward striven for in a competitive contest; anything offered to be competed for, or as an inducement to, or reward of, effort. — 奖;奖品 such as the Nobels or the Fields medal: the top international prize in mathematics, awarded every four years — 「菲尔兹奖」. Music was the hardest, but the team used a study from UC Davis that ranked composer: A person who writes music. — 作曲家 by expert opinion and how often their works were performed in opera: A theatrical work, combining drama, music, song and sometimes dance; usually, one sung-through, based on classical music and seen as more artistic and formalized than other forms of musical theater. — 歌剧 houses.

The pattern was reliable across every field. Elite young performers and elite adults turned out to be almost completely different groups. Around 90% of adult superstars had not been superstars as children, while only 10% of top-level children went on to become exceptional: Better than the average; superior due to exception or rarity. — 杰出的;非凡的 adults. In fact, childhood and adult excellence: The quality of being excellent; brilliance — 卓越;优秀 were slightly negatively correlate: To be related by a correlation; to be correlated. — 相关;相互关联. The adults who did reach the top had kept broad: Wide in extent or scope. — 广泛的 interests. The best sportsmen and women had played several sports at a fairly high level for longer than their more focused peer: Somebody who is, or something that is, at a level or of a value equal (to that of something else). — 同等的人;同侪. They were behind early on, but once they specialize: To focus one's study upon a particular skill, field, topic, or genre. — 专攻;专门从事, they improved much faster—they had better training efficiency: how much an athlete improves per unit of training time — 「训练效率」. Even Nobel-winning scientists were less likely than their nominee: A person named, or designated, by another, to any office, duty, or position; one nominated, or proposed, by others for office or for election to office. — 被提名人;候选人 to have won academic scholarships as students.

Why does this pattern keep repeating? The researchers offer three possible explanations. The first comes from labour-market economics: Chiefly with a descriptive word: the application of this study to a particular domain. — (某领域的)经济学 and is called search and match: an economic idea: trying many options first helps you find the one that fits you best — 「搜寻与匹配」理论: trying many things first helps you find the field that fits you best (Rafael Nadal, for example, played football seriously before choosing tennis). The second is “enhanced learning”: learning is itself a skill, and exploring variety sharpen: To make sharp. — 使锋利;削尖 it. The third is the limited-risk hypothesis: the idea that delaying specialisation protects young people from burnout or boredom — 「有限风险假说」—avoiding the hothouse: An environment in which growth or development is encouraged naturally or artificially; a hotbed. — 高压环境;温室 may stop young people from burning out: becoming completely exhausted from too much pressure or effort — 「燃烧殆尽 / 倦怠」 or losing interest entirely: To the full or entire extent. — 完全地;全部地.

Güllich is careful with his conclusions. The hothouse model still works, he says. It produces highly competent: Having sufficient skill, knowledge, ability, or qualifications. — 有能力的;胜任的 people—just not the world's very best. But selective: Choosy, fussy or discriminating when selecting. — 挑剔的;讲究的 schools, sports academies and music conservatoire: A music academy. — 音乐学院 may want to think again about how they train their youngest stars.

Questions

Check your understanding

  1. 01

    According to the article, what did Güllich's study find about teenagers who trained the hardest and performed best as children?

  2. 02

    Reread the paragraph that lists the three possible explanations. Why does the writer mention Rafael Nadal?

  3. 03

    What is the main idea the article is building towards?

  4. 04

    How does the writer use the opening story about Novak Djokovic to shape the argument of the article?

    Suggested length: ~80 words

  5. 05

    Evaluate how convincing the article's case is that selective academies should rethink how they train young people.

    Suggested length: ~80 words