Teacher's Note

Why read this: This article uses a clear three-way comparison — Jakarta, Dhaka and Delhi versus Tokyo — to argue that Asian megacities feel hard to live in mainly because authority is shared badly between local offices, not because they are too poor. The piece is short and concrete, so B2 readers can follow the reasoning while still meeting cross-subject academic vocabulary like 'governance', 'metropolitan area' and 'middle-income trap'. It also gives students a useful real-world example of cause and effect: fragmented authority leads to traffic, pollution and wasted infrastructure, even when there is money to spend.

What to notice: Watch how the writer builds an argument by accumulating evidence rather than stating a thesis on the first line. The opening paragraph reframes which city is biggest; only in paragraphs four and five does the central claim about fragmented governance appear, supported by Jakarta's traffic, the metro line that stops at the city border, and the divided authority across Dhaka and Delhi. Notice also the contrast structure: problems are clustered in Jakarta, then Tokyo is offered as a counter-model. Pay attention to hedging words ('can wipe out', 'could be huge', 'does not always cost a fortune'); they show that the writer is making a likely argument, not stating a certainty. Finally, look at how named examples (the metro line, Adhika Ajie's quote, the train statistic about Tokyo) are used as evidence rather than decoration.

Skills practised: Comparison-contrast reading across more than two cases; tracking a delayed thesis through several paragraphs; recognising cause-and-effect signalled by 'because', 'so' and 'as a result'; reading hedged claims accurately rather than as absolute statements; and using context plus margin glosses to handle B2-level academic vocabulary like 'metropolitan area', 'centralised authority' and 'satellite cities'. Students also practise turning evidence into a one-sentence summary and evaluating whether the article's prescriptive conclusion follows from the evidence presented.

Level: B2 · Length: ~640 words · Reading time: ~3 min
Graded ReadingB2

Why Asia's biggest cities feel so hard to live in

Jakarta, Dhaka and Delhi struggle with traffic and pollution. Tokyo shows a calmer way to run a giant city.

~3 min read·

Tap any green word in the article to see its meaning.

For seventy years Tokyo was thought to be the world's biggest city, but new UN figures released last month tell a different story. Until recently the UN counted only people living inside each country's official city limits, and the new report finally accepts the reality of urban sprawl: the way a city's built-up area spreads outward into surrounding land — 城市蔓延. Jakarta, Indonesia's capital, now tops the list with 42 million people — almost as many as live in Canada. Dhaka, the capital of Bangladesh, has reached 37 million, while Delhi follows close behind. Tokyo, once the largest, has slipped to fourth place with 33 million.

These numbers point to huge urban growth, and most of it is happening in middle-income Asia, where only one of the world's ten biggest cities lie: To be placed or situated. — 位于 outside the region. By 2050 Jakarta and Dhaka together will add another 25 million people. Most newcomer: One who has recently come to a community; a recent arrival. — 新来者;新到的人 move there hoping for a better life. "Dhaka changed my life and secure: To put beyond hazard of losing or of not receiving; to make certain; to assure; frequently with against or from, or formerly with of. — 获得;确保 my kids' education: The process of imparting knowledge, skill and judgment. — 教育;教育过程," says Clinton Chakma, a waiter who arrived from a farm in 2022.

Yet there is also a real risk: as Asian cities grow, dirt, pollution and traffic can wipe: To move an object over, maintaining contact, with the intention of removing some substance from the surface. (Compare rub.) — 擦;擦去 out the economic gains they bring. "People move to cities to be part of the labour market: the system in which people look for jobs and employers look for workers — 劳动力市场," says Alain Bertaud of New York University, but when that market does not work properly, poor people simply stay poor. Today Jakarta, Dhaka and Delhi all rank among the worst cities to live in, according to the Economist Intelligence Unit, and Dhaka comes third from last in the world.

If Asian countries want to escape the middle-income trap: an economic situation where a country gets stuck at a moderate income level and stops getting richer — 中等收入陷阱, they must fix the problems that damage their cities. The best way to do so is not by building one project at a time but by changing how cities are run. Jakarta is a useful example: over the years it has swallow: To take (something) in so that it disappears; to consume, absorb. — 吞没;吞并 several satellite cities: smaller cities that grow up around a bigger central city — 卫星城 around it, yet there is almost no cooperation: The act of cooperating. — 合作;协作 among their separate governments. A metropolitan area: a big city plus the smaller towns and suburbs around it that work as one connected area — 都市圈(大都会区) as large as a small country is therefore run like a noisy crowd of strangers.

The price of this fragmented governance: a way of running a city where authority is split across many separate offices that don't coordinate — 碎片化治理 is clearest in Jakarta's awful traffic, which ranks twelfth most jammed in the world. Dhaka comes third and Delhi seventh. Because many workers cannot afford homes near their offices, they live in far-flung suburbs: outer suburbs that are very far from the city centre — 偏远郊区 and rely: To depend; to be dependent upon. — 依赖;依靠 on cars or scooter: A kick scooter or push scooter; a human-powered land vehicle with a handlebar, deck and wheels that is propelled by a rider pushing off the ground. — 踏板车;滑板车 since public transport is poor. The result is constant: Consistently recurring over time; persistent. — 持续不断的;不断的 gridlock: A condition of total, interlocking traffic congestion on the streets or highways of a crowded city, in which no one can move because everyone is in someone else's way. — (交通)大堵塞;瘫痪 and dirty air, and Jakarta's government estimate: To calculate roughly, often from imperfect data. — 估计 that traffic jams cost the local economy six billion dollars every year.

Jakarta opened its first metro: A rapid transit rail transport system, or a train in such systems, generally underground and serving a metropolitan area. — 地铁 line in 2019, but it stops at the city's official border, well short of the suburbs where most workers actually live. "Without coordination: The act of coordinating, making different people or things work together for a goal or effect. — 协调;配合 across the whole urban area, it is useless: Unhelpful, not useful; pointless (of an action). — 徒劳的;没用的," says Adhika Ajie, a senior: Higher in rank, dignity, or office; superior. — 高级的;资深的 researcher in Jakarta's city government. Dhaka and Delhi face similar problems, with authority split: To share; to divide. — 分摊;分享 between city offices, the state, the national government and many other agency: A department or other administrative unit of a government; also, the office or headquarters of, or the district administered by, such unit of government. — (政府)机构;局 that rarely talk to one another.

Tokyo offers a better model. The Tokyo Metropolitan Government handle: To treat, to deal with (in a specified way). — 处理;应对 big city-wide services such as water, sewage: A suspension of water and solid waste, transported by sewers to be disposed of or processed. — 污水;下水道污物 and hospitals, while twenty-three smaller district: An area or region marked by some distinguishing feature. — 区;地区 and many neighbouring: Situated or living nearby or adjacent to. — 邻近的;相邻的 towns sit beneath: In a position that is lower in rank, dignity, etc. — 有失……身份;不值得 it, each with its own elect: (Of a group) to officially select one or more candidates in an election to hold office. — 选举;推选 mayor: The chief executive of the municipal government of a city, borough, etc., formerly (historical) usually appointed as a caretaker by European royal courts but now usually appointed or elected locally. — 市长. These local council: A local authority. — 地方议会;市政府 look after schools, waste management: the system of collecting, sorting and disposing of rubbish — 废物管理 and parks, and the metropolitan government coordinates between them. The result is a sensible: Acting with or showing good sense; able to make good judgements based on reason or wisdom, or reflecting such ability. — 明智的;合情合理的 split of duties rather than one centralised authority: decision-making power held in one main place rather than spread across many offices — 集中(化)的权力. A dense: Compact; crowded together. — 密集的;稠密的 train network ties everything together, and more than ninety percent of people in greater Tokyo live within a twenty-minute walk of a station.

Of course, Tokyo is far richer than Jakarta or Dhaka, and when it first reached twenty million people in 1965 Japan was already a wealthy: Possessing financial wealth; rich. — 富裕的;有钱的 country. But Asia's poorer megacity: A very large city; a megalopolis, typically one with population over 10 million. — 特大城市 do not need to wait for wealth: Riches; a great amount of valuable assets or material possessions. — 财富;财产 before improving, because better governance does not always cost a fortune: Destiny, especially favorable. — 命运;运势. reform: To put into a new and improved form or condition; to restore to a former good state, or bring from bad to good; to change from worse to better. — 改革;改进 how power is shared is harder than simply spending money on big projects, but the reward: The result of an action, whether good or bad. — 回报;报答 could be huge.

Questions

Check your understanding

  1. 01

    According to the article, why has Tokyo dropped from first to fourth place in the UN's list of biggest cities?

  2. 02

    What does the article say is the main reason Jakarta's traffic is so bad?

  3. 03

    Which sentence best summarises the article's overall argument?

  4. 04

    How does Tokyo's system of local councils help avoid the problems that Jakarta faces? Use details from the article to support your answer.

    Suggested length: ~80 words

  5. 05

    Evaluate the claim that fixing governance is more important than spending money on big projects in Asia's megacities. Do you find the article's argument convincing? Why or why not?

    Suggested length: ~80 words